The “Anchor Price” Scam: Why Amazon’s “50% Off” Deals Are Often Lies

by

This tool reveals the truth. The 'Sale Price' is often just the normal price disguised as a deal

You know the feeling.

You are scrolling through Amazon, or walking through a Best Buy, and you see it. A shiny new pair of headphones or a 4K TV with a price tag that looks too good to be true:

  • ~~$399.99~~ $199.99 (50% OFF!)

Your brain releases a sudden hit of dopamine. You panic. You think, “Wow, I am saving $200! I need to buy this right now before the price goes back up!”

I hate to be the one to break it to you, but you probably didn’t save $200. In fact, you likely paid exactly what the product is worth.

That crossed-out number ($399) is not a real price. It is a psychological weapon called a “Price Anchor.” It is designed to shut down your logical brain and open your wallet.

Here is how the trick works, why your brain falls for it, and the simple browser tool I use to defeat it.

1. Hacking Your Brain: What is “Anchoring”?

In behavioral psychology, Anchoring is a cognitive bias where humans rely too heavily on the first piece of information offered (the “anchor”) when making decisions.

Once an anchor is set, all other judgments are made by adjusting away from that anchor.

Let me give you two scenarios:

  • Scenario A: You walk into a store and see a watch for $150. You think, “That’s expensive for a watch.” You walk away.

  • Scenario B: You walk into a store. The sign says “LUXURY WATCHES.” You see a watch marked ~~$1,000~~, now only $150. You think, “What a steal! That is an $850 discount!”

In both scenarios, the price is $150. The watch is the same. The money leaving your bank account is the same. But in Scenario B, the store gave you a fake “Anchor” ($1,000). Compared to the anchor, $150 feels tiny.

Retailers know this. They artificially inflate the “List Price” (MSRP) to a number nobody ever actually pays, just so they can show you a fake discount.

2. The Amazon “Prime Day” Trick

This happens constantly in the world of online shopping.

I recently tracked a popular Robot Vacuum cleaner.

  • April: Price was $250.

  • May: Price was $250.

  • June (2 weeks before Prime Day): The price suddenly jumped to $400.

  • July (Prime Day): The listing screamed: “HUGE DEAL! Was $400, Now $250!”

Technically, the listing wasn’t lying. It was $400 last week. But for 90% of the year, it was $250. The “Deal” was an illusion. The company manipulated the price history to create a fake anchor.

3. The “Outlet Store” Secret

This trick isn’t just online. It is the entire business model of “Factory Outlet” malls.

When you walk into a designer outlet store, you see tags that say: “Compare at $120. Our Price: $40.”

You assume you are buying a $120 shirt that simply didn’t sell at the main luxury store. You are wrong.

Most big brands manufacture cheap, lower-quality clothes specifically for the outlet store.

  • The fabric is thinner.

  • The stitching is cheaper.

  • The buttons are plastic instead of metal.

That shirt was never $120. It was manufactured to be sold for $40. The “$120” anchor is pure fiction designed to make you feel like a smart shopper.

4. How to Beat the Anchor (The “Camel” Strategy)

So, how do you know if a sale is real? I have a strict rule: I never look at the crossed-out number. It is a lie. I only look at the current price.

To find the real value, I use a free tool called CamelCamelCamel (or Keepa). These are browser extensions that show you a graph of the product’s price history on Amazon.

My Shopping Workflow:

  1. I see a “Deal” on Amazon (e.g., “50% Off!”).

  2. I copy the Amazon URL.

  3. I paste it into CamelCamelCamel.com.

  4. I look at the “Average Price” line.

If the “Deal Price” is lower than the Average Price, it is a real sale. If the “Deal Price” is the same as the Average Price, I know the “50% Off” tag is a scam.

5. The “Smart Price” Mindset Shift

The next time you see a giant red “SALE” sign, do not ask yourself: “How much am I saving?” Instead, ask yourself: “If this product had no discount tag, would I still buy it at this price?”

Marketing creates urgency. They want you to panic-buy because of “Fear Of Missing Out” (FOMO). But remember:

  • You didn’t save $200.

  • You spent $199.

If you wouldn’t buy it at full price, you don’t need it at half price.

Leave a Comment